Amish Strawberry Pie Recipe For Old School Comfort

Amish strawberry pie holds a special place in the world of homestyle baking, beloved for its wholesome simplicity and genuinely comforting character.

Rooted in tradition, it carries the kind of warmth that feels both familiar and deeply satisfying with every single bite.

Few desserts manage to feel this honest and unpretentious while still impressing everyone at the table.

Sweet, fresh, and beautifully simple, it strikes a perfect balance between rustic charm and crowd-pleasing appeal.

Baking it feels like a quiet celebration of good ingredients and time-honored technique – no fuss, no shortcuts, just pure, wholesome goodness.

If you appreciate desserts that speak for themselves without needing anything extra, this is exactly the kind of recipe worth having in your collection.

Head straight to the recipe and see just how rewarding classic, simple baking can truly be.

The Charm of Amish Strawberry Pie

• Family Favorite That Feels Special: Your family gets a homemade pie that tastes like something from a traditional kitchen, and the strawberries stay bright and fresh so each bite feels genuine.
• Hands-On But Manageable: The steps are straightforward enough that you can handle the cooking without stress, since most of the work is just stirring and letting things cool down naturally.
• Makes Your Kitchen Smell Amazing: When you’re making this, your home fills with that warm strawberry and buttery crust aroma that just makes people happy when they walk in.
• No Last-Minute Rushing: Because you refrigerate it overnight, you finish the hard part ahead of time, so when guests arrive or dinner happens, your dessert is already waiting chilled and ready for you to serve.

Ingredient Collection for Amish Strawberry Pie

• Amish Never Fail Pie Crust (1 recipe): Prepared crust forms the foundation for this pie and needs to be baked according to its own recipe instructions.

• Water (2 cups): Creates the liquid base for your glossy filling.
• Corn Starch (⅓ cup): Thickens your filling so it sets properly in the pie.
• Granulated Sugar (½ cup): Sweetener balances the tartness of the strawberries.
• Strawberry Gelatin (⅓ cup): Adds both flavor and extra setting power to your filling.
• Fresh Strawberries (1 quart): Hulled and quartered berries are the star of this pie.

• Whipped Topping (as needed): A dollop of this goes on top of each slice you serve.

Which Equipment Works Best For Amish Strawberry Pie

• Deep-Dish Pie Pan: You’ll need a 9 or 10-inch pan to hold your crust and filling securely as it bakes and sets.
• Medium Saucepan: This is where you combine your water, cornstarch, and sugar, so choose one that gives you enough room to stir comfortably.
• Wooden Spoon: You use this to stir your mixture continuously as it heats and comes to a boil.
• Measuring Cups: Your recipe depends on accurate measurements, so grab a set to portion out water and other liquid ingredients.
• Measuring Spoons: These help you measure the cornstarch and gelatin precisely for the right consistency.
• Pie Crust: The Amish Never Fail variety is what lines your pan before baking.
• Oven: You need this to bake your pie crust according to its instructions.
• Rubber Spatula: This tool works well for gently folding strawberries into your cooled gelatin mixture without crushing them.
• Whisk: Having one on hand helps blend your dry ingredients smoothly before adding liquid.
• Small Bowl: Use this to dissolve your gelatin before stirring it into the warm mixture.
• Serving Utensil: A pie server or cake knife makes it easy to cut clean slices when serving chilled.

Preparation Directions For Amish Strawberry Pie

Amish Strawberry Pie Cooking Ideas That Help

• Bake Your Crust Fully: Make sure your pie shell is completely baked before filling it, so the bottom doesn’t turn soggy when you add the strawberry mixture.
• Stir The Glaze Constantly: Keep stirring that cornstarch mixture while it heats up and boils; this prevents lumps from forming and helps everything thicken evenly.
• Cool Before Adding Berries: Let the glaze cool down completely before folding in your strawberries, since hot liquid can break them apart and make your pie look mushy.
• Don’t Rush The Chill Time: Giving your pie a full overnight in the refrigerator lets the gelatin set properly, so each slice holds together nicely when you cut it.
• Fresh Strawberries Work Best: Use berries that are ripe but still firm; softer ones tend to fall apart when you mix them into the glaze, affecting your pie’s texture.

Flavor Options for Amish Strawberry Pie

• Raspberry or Blackberry Version: Swap the strawberries for the same amount of fresh raspberries or blackberries, keeping everything else the same since these berries work just as well in the gelatin filling and give you a deeper color.
• Coconut Cream Topping: Replace the whipped cream with a mixture of whipped coconut cream and a tablespoon of coconut extract, which pairs nicely with the berry filling when your household prefers coconut flavors.
• No-Gelatin Option: If you don’t have gelatin on hand, increase the cornstarch to 3 tablespoons instead of 2, and this will thicken your filling just as effectively without changing the berry ratio.
• Dairy-Free Crust and Topping: Use your favorite vegan pie crust and top with coconut whipped cream or cashew cream, making the entire pie suitable for you if you avoid dairy products.

Sweet Pairings for Amish Strawberry Pie

• Serve With Vanilla Ice Cream: This pie tastes wonderful when paired with a scoop of vanilla ice cream that melts into the filling as you eat it.
• Pair With Shortcake For Brunch: The strawberry filling works beautifully alongside buttery shortcake at a morning gathering, and your guests can build their own plates.
• Add Whipped Cream And Fresh Mint: A dollop of whipped cream on each slice gives you a lighter topping option, especially when garnished with a small sprig of mint for a fresh touch.
• Serve Chilled At Potlucks: Since this pie needs to sit overnight anyway, bring it to your next family gathering straight from the refrigerator; it holds up well and feeds a crowd easily.

Clever Storage Advice For Amish Strawberry Pie

• Store your finished pie in the refrigerator covered loosely with plastic wrap or foil, and it stays fresh for up to three days, giving you time to enjoy slices throughout the week.
• Keep the strawberry filling separate from the crust if your pie starts getting soggy before you finish it; transfer any remaining filling to a container and serve it over vanilla ice cream instead.
• Your pie tastes best when chilled, so avoid leaving it on the counter for more than two hours, especially on warm days when the gelatin softens quickly.
• Freeze unbaked pie crust in the pan for up to a month if you want to prep ahead, then bake it fresh the morning you plan to make your filling and assemble everything.

FAQs

Amish Strawberry Pie Recipe

---

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

4.7 from 35 reviews

• Total Time: 8 hours (including Chilling time)
• Yield: 8 1x

Print Recipe

Pin Recipe

Description

When life calls for a dessert that feels like pure comfort, Amish strawberry pie comes through with fresh berries and a flaky crust that you’ll find yourself making again and again. Jammy filling meets buttery pastry in a way that brings folks around your table together, simple and satisfying.

---

Ingredients

Scale 1x2x3x

Crust and Garnish:

• 1 Amish never fail pie crust
• Whipped topping to garnish

Filling Base:

• 2 cups water
• 1/3 cup corn starch
• 1/2 cup granulated sugar
• 1/3 cup strawberry gelatin

Fruit:

• 1 quart fresh strawberries, hulled and quartered

Cook Mode Prevent your screen from going dark

---

Instructions

1. Get your Amish Never Fail Pie Crust prepared and baked according to its directions in a deep-dish pie pan.
2. Combine 2 cups of water, ⅓ cup corn starch, and ½ cup granulated sugar in a medium saucepan over medium heat, stirring constantly until the mixture dissolves completely.
3. Keep stirring as your mixture reaches a boil and let it continue at a rolling boil for about 1 minute.
4. Turn your heat down to low and let the thickened mixture simmer for 10 minutes, giving it an occasional stir.
5. Move your saucepan off the heat and add ⅓ cup strawberry gelatin, stirring until it fully dissolves into the warm mixture.
6. Let your gelatin mixture cool to room temperature before folding in your 1 quart of fresh hulled and quartered strawberries gently so they hold their shape.
7. Pour all 2 cups of your strawberry filling into your baked crust and refrigerate for at least 8 hours or overnight until the filling sets completely.
8. Slice your pie and top each serving with a dollop of whipped topping if that appeals to you.

Notes

• Cook your cornstarch mixture slowly and stir constantly to prevent lumps from forming in the filling.
• Let the cooked mixture cool completely before folding in the strawberries so the heat doesn’t break them down into mush.
• Refrigerate the pie for the full overnight time because rushing this step means your filling won’t set properly and the pie will be runny.
• Fresh strawberries work best here, but frozen ones (thawed and drained well) work in a pinch as long as you squeeze out excess moisture so it doesn’t water down your filling.

• Prep Time: 15 minutes
• Cook Time: 15 minutes
• Category: Pies
• Method: Baking
• Cuisine: American

Nutrition

• Serving Size: 8
• Calories: 120 kcal
• Sugar: 20 g
• Sodium: 10 mg
• Fat: 0.2 g
• Saturated Fat: 0 g
• Unsaturated Fat: 0.1 g
• Trans Fat: 0 g
• Carbohydrates: 30 g
• Fiber: 2 g
• Protein: 1 g
• Cholesterol: 0 mg